From Clinicals to the Courtroom: Ivy Tech Muncie Nursing Program Hosts Malpractice Mock Trial

From Clinicals to the Courtroom: Ivy Tech Muncie Nursing Program Hosts Malpractice Mock TrialPhoto provided by Ivy Tech nursing.

By Lesley DeVoss—

MUNCIE, IN —Nurses serve on the front lines of emergency rooms, clinics, and hospitals in high-stress, fast-paced environments. Beyond delivering bedside care, future nurses carry a critical responsibility to accurately document every step of a patient’s journey—because one day, those records could be examined in a court of law.

To bring that reality to life, the School of Nursing at Ivy Tech Community College Muncie hosted an immersive mock trial on November 16, giving students firsthand experience in how clinical charting holds up under legal scrutiny.

The mock trial was something Nursing Department Chair Stormi Hatfield had planned to put together for several years. After closely following a recent court case featuring healthcare professionals taking the stand, she recognized how critical thorough documentation is—and how quickly gaps in charting can undermine both a provider’s credibility and patient safety.

Developed with the support of local attorney NiCale L. Rector and Simulation Coordinator Krista Turner, the simulation centered on a fictional case in which a plaintiff’s family alleged that “Ivy Tech Community Hospital” failed to provide adequate discharge and care information following a patient’s stay. During the exercise, participating nursing students took the witness stand, where their clinical documentation was scrutinized by attorneys and they were required to defend their care decisions.

“The mock trial is so important to hospital staff. It affords them the opportunity to truly understand why the little things often become the big things,” Rector said. “It provided students a firsthand look at how simply taking a short cut or omitting something that seems small, such as a date, can turn into a major issue and create a lot of unnecessary stress in their lives.  The trial provided them with a real-life experience without the real-life consequence that could ultimately follow.”

“Our students are expected to treat all simulations as though they are happening in the real world. Their documentation must match what they will be expected to do in an actual life-or-death situation in a hospital or clinic,” said Che’Reese Anderson, Dean for the School of Nursing. “Through experiences such as this mock trial, they are shown just how important this skill truly is. A well-documented interaction makes the difference between proving you followed all procedures and being held responsible for cutting corners.”

Throughout the trial, one foundational healthcare maxim served as the running theme: If it wasn’t documented, it didn’t happen. In a realistic twist, the students called to the stand had to defend actual documentation they had created during an earlier nursing simulation lab. Students quickly saw that a court of law relies on written evidence rather than memory, and a witness’s insistence that a step was taken carries little weight without accurate charting to back it up. While medical malpractice suits represent roughly one percent of civil jury trials, healthcare professionals at every level must be prepared for that possibility.

Adrianna Horn, a nursing student in her final semester with the Nursing Program, was one of two students who took the stand on Monday. Rector pressed Horn regarding the quality of the documentation presented as evidence during the mock trial.

“This was one of the best experiences that I have been a part of during nursing school. I was one of two students called up to the stand and was questioned by the lawyer. She did not go easy on me!” Horn said. “The whole experience from start to finish felt like a real life court! It really drilled into my brain the importance of good charting and documentation when I become a nurse. I really appreciate everything that the nursing instructors at Ivy Tech Muncie do to make their students successful.”

Not every student was in the hot seat; dozens of peers observed from the gallery and served on the jury, weighing the evidence presented before them.

“Participating in the mock trial as a jury member was such a cool and eye-opening experience,” said Ivy Tech Muncie nursing student Emma Tate. “It really showed us just how important it is to be extremely thorough with our charting and documentation—especially considering something we document today could be presented 10 years from now. You are always told that charting is important, and it absolutely is, but seeing it from the trial perspective really locks it into your head.”

Each year, Ivy Tech Muncie nursing graduates step into vital roles at hospitals and clinics across East Central Indiana. Hands-on simulations like the mock trial ensure graduates leave campus well-versed in both clinical patient safety and the legal standards of professional healthcare.

To learn more about the nursing program at Ivy Tech Community College Muncie, visit ivytech.edu/nursing.

 

About Ivy Tech Community College

Ivy Tech Community College is Indiana’s largest public postsecondary institution and the nation’s largest singly accredited statewide community college system, serving more than 200,000 students annually throughout the state. Ivy Tech serves as the state’s workforce engine, offering more than 70 programs that provide pathways to high-quality education and training aligned to in-demand careers, needed by Hoosier communities. The College awards credentials that are stackable toward industry certifications, short-term certificate programs, and associate degrees that seamlessly transfer to other colleges and universities in Indiana for a more affordable route to bachelor’s degrees and beyond.